At the intersection of sexual and reproductive health and HIV services: use of moderately effective family planning among female sex workers in Kampala, Uganda

The burden of HIV among female sex workers (FSW) has been well documented and data on progress toward the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS) 90–90-90 targets—90% of people living with HIV are diagnosed, 90% of them are on treatment, and 90% of them have suppressed viral load—are slowly becoming available [1‐4]. FSW are 13.5 times as likely as women in the general population of lower and middle income countries to be infected with HIV and 5% of new HIV infections are among FSW in these countries [5]. Lower educational level, poverty, and mobility among FSW also may impact HIV acquisition or reduce health service uptake [6‐9]. Missing, however, is an understanding of the sexual and reproductive lives of FSW, lives that are intricately connected with HIV risk and service uptake, but which are not integrated and instead addressed separately or not at all, both in the literature and in service delivery [10‐13].

In addition to HIV, multiple sexual partners and inconsistent condom use make FSW vulnerable to other sexually transmitted diseases (STD) [5, 14]. These behaviors and low use of modern methods of family planning (FP) also make them vulnerable to unintended pregnancies [5, 14]. Research has shown that most FSW have had at least one pregnancy in their lifetime and more than half of FSW are estimated to have a curable STD at a given time [13, 15‐17]. Pregnancy during sex work has also been associated with fewer live births and more terminated pregnancies [18].

The 2016 Uganda Demographic Health Survey (UDHS) found that 47% of sexually active unmarried women and 35% of married women used modern contraception (Macro International & Uganda Bureau of Statistics, 2018). Among sexually active unmarried women, injectables were the most common method (21%), followed by male condoms (14%). Nearly half (45%) of episodes of contraceptive use in the 5 years preceding the UDHS survey were discontinued within 12 months. Contraceptive discontinuation rates were highest for oral hormonal contraception (67%) and long-acting injectables (52%) and lowest for implants (21%). Discontinuation occurred most frequently due to health concerns or side effects. The survey also found that 41% of births or current pregnancies were mistimed or unwanted [19]. Consequently, the Ugandan Ministry of Health estimates that unsafe termination of pregnancies are responsible for 8% of maternal deaths [20].

A 2012 biobehavioral survey was conducted in Kampala, Uganda to characterize HIV prevalence and viral load suppression among FSW. The survey estimated HIV prevalence at 31.4% in this population. Among FSW living with HIV, 45.5% were aware of their infection [9]. Syphilis prevalence was 6.2% [9]. Sexually transmitted diseases are also common among FSW in Kampala. In 2008, approximately 22% had syphilis, 9% trichomonas vaginalis, 8% vaginal gonorrhea, 4% anorectal gonorrhea, 4% vaginal chlamydia, and 2% anorectal chlamydia [17, 21]. Here we examine uptake of reproductive health services among FSW in Kampala, Uganda, and factors associated with using at least a moderately effective method of FP defined here as including: oral hormonal contraception, long-acting injectables, implant, and intrauterine devices [22].

Based on experience in a previous survey of FSW in Kampala, we utilized respondent-driven sampling (RDS) to recruit up to 1,500 FSW into the CRANE Survey between April and December 2012. The CRANE survey aimed to characterize HIV prevalence, risks behaviors, and health service utilization among FSW. RDS is a variant of snowball sampling that yields a probability-based sample [23‐25]. Eligibility criteria included age 15 years or older, residence in greater Kampala, and having sold sex to men in the last six months. Recruitment began with four purposively selected seeds identified by survey staff. Seeds were selected to be diverse in terms of age, type of venue where they find clients (e.g., street, bar, hotel), and neighborhood where they find clients. At the first survey visit, participants were given the equivalent of $4 US in Ugandan Shillings for their time and transportation. Those who successfully recruited peers who participated in the survey prior to the second visit received an additional amount in Ugandan Shillings equivalent to $1.25 US per recruit. Participants could recruit a maximum of three people. This was reduced gradually to two, one, and finally zero as the desired sample size was attained. Detailed methods have been described elsewhere [9].

We enrolled and analyzed data from 1,497 FSW. The median age of FSW in Kampala was 27 years and 32.7% were between the ages of 15 and 24 years (Table 1). Almost half (49.5%) had never been married. And 59.6% had at least one steady sex partner in the last six months (data not shown). One-fifth (22.2%) had sold sex for less than one year and 35.6% for 1–2 years.

Table 2 shows sexual behaviors and reproductive health characteristics among Kampala FSW. Less than 1 in 10 FSW (9.5%) had anal sex in their lifetime. Approximately two-thirds (65.2%) of FSW used a condom at last sex. Pregnancy history was common among FSW, with 88.6% having been pregnant and 8.6% currently pregnant. Over one-quarter (27.2%) had given birth to at least four children. A similar proportion (29.9%) had had at least one miscarriage and 37.4% had terminated one or more pregnancies. An estimated 35.3% were not using use any form of FP, including condoms, to prevent pregnancy, and 19.4% did not have easy access to FP services. Roughly equal proportions of those who were pregnant and those who were not pregnant did not have easy access to FP (data not shown). Among FSW using FP, a variety of methods were used, including injectables (55.4%), oral contraception (18.1%), implants (3.7%), and intrauterine devices (2.4%). Condoms were relied upon by 19.7% of FSW using a FP method.

While lubricants were used by 36.0% of FSW, 52.4% of those who used lubricants used oil-based lubricants (Table 3). Symptoms of sexually transmitted diseases were common, with 89.8% of FSW reporting at least one in the last six months (Table 3). Of those with symptoms, 63.0% reportedly had lesions or ulcers and 22.5% reported warts (data not shown). Though 68.5% of FSW with STD symptoms sought treatment from a hospital, clinic, or pharmacy, 31.4% either self-treated or did not access treatment at all. Among those who sought treatment from a hospital, clinic, or pharmacy, 35.9% felt stigmatized by healthcare provider. Meanwhile, 17.1% of FSW felt they did not have easy access to STD treatment. Just over half of FSW with STD symptoms (53.6%) stopped having sex when they had an STD.

In multivariable analysis (Table 4), the odds of using at least a moderately effective method of FP was higher among women who had not experienced stigma from a healthcare worker when obtaining STD treatment in the last six months compared to those who had (aOR: 1.6, 95% CI: 1.1–2.4) and 2. Women who have given birth to 2–3 children (aOR: 2.5, 95% CI: 1.4–4.8) and 4–5 children (aOR: 2.9, 95% CI: 1.4–5.9) It is plausible that those living with HIV are also less likely than those without it to be using a moderately effective method of FP (aOR: 0.7, 95% CI: 0.5–1.0).

Approximately half (52.7%) FSW in Kampala used at least a moderately effective method of family planning [26]. Barriers to FP are many and may include an unsupportive health clinic environment, including inconvenient hours and discriminatory providers as key barriers to contraceptive use [27]. We found that 35.9% of FSW with an STD felt stigmatized by healthcare workers when seeking STD treatment. Sex worker experiences of stigmatization by healthcare providers have been well documented but little data exist reflecting its impact on healthcare utilization [28‐31]. We found that for FSW in Kampala, increased odds of using at least a moderately effective method of FP was associated with stigma-free STD services. Key population sensitization training for healthcare providers can facilitate the expansion of stigma-free services for FSW therefore has the potential to increase utilization of moderately effective FP methods. It is plausible that the use of moderately effective FP was also inversely associated with living with HIV, suggesting that there may not be integration of HIV and reproductive health services. This has important clinical and public health implications, particularly if those living with HIV have not attained viral suppression.

Sexually transmitted diseases are a risk factor for HIV acquisition and transmission [32, 33]. They are also a public health problem in their own right, particularly for a population such as FSW with high prevalence of STDs such as syphilis that can affect birth outcomes [34, 35]. Nearly nine in ten experienced STD symptoms in the last six months. Approximately two-thirds (68.5%) of those with STD symptoms sought treatment at a hospital, clinic, or pharmacy. In contrast, though approximately one-third of FSW in Kampala were living with HIV, 28.1% of FSW had never tested for HIV and of those who have, 67.6% did so in the last 12 months, and self-reported awareness of living with HIV was 45.5% [9]. Though STD prevalence is lower than HIV prevalence among FSW in Kampala, FSW seem more inclined to seek care for STD symptoms than they do testing for HIV, perhaps because they experienced symptoms that needed to be addressed.

Many FSW are more interested in testing and treatment for STD than for HIV, possibly because until the late stages of the disease HIV may go unnoticed, whereas STD symptoms cause discomfort, may be more obvious to others, and may negatively impact their ability to earn money [29]. Furthermore, most STD can be cured, usually with one to three clinic visits [34‐36]. STD screening, testing, and treatment provision can potentially attract women to health services where they may also be offered pregnancy testing and linkage to maternity care if pregnant, FP and HIV testing. STD services consequently are an opportunity not only for FP and HIV testing, but to inform women about the benefits of these services, for themselves and others, including children they may have in the future. For such integrated services to be successful, it is imperative that they be provided in a stigma-free environment.

In 2008, the median duration of sex work among current FSW was three years [17]. By 2012, the median duration was two years, suggesting that women may be remaining in sex work for less time. This scenario of a higher turnover rate could lend itself to unchanged HIV and STD incidence among FSW as those entering the profession would be less likely to already be infected than those who have been in it for longer. This is supported by the unchanged HIV prevalence among FSW in Kampala between 2008 and 2012 [17]. And as these FSW become infected with HIV and remain undiagnosed and not on antiretroviral treatment (ART), population viral load will remain elevated and consequently so will the potential for transmission to clients and then from clients to other sex workers and the general population.

Although abortion is illegal in Uganda, 37.4% of FSW have terminated at least one pregnancy in their lifetime, similar to other locations in sub-Saharan Africa [37]. Unable to obtain an abortion from trained healthcare providers, FSW may terminate their pregnancies on their own or with the assistance of unskilled individuals, thereby increasing the risk of maternal morbidity and mortality [37‐39]. It also points to the potential unmet need for effective methods of FP.

Our findings are limited by the cross-sectional nature of our survey and that we did not ask participants if they obtain HIV, STI, and FP services from a single integrated site or separate sites, though at the time of data collection FSW service providers were focused primarily on HIV. We also did not ask women if they were trying to avoid pregnancy and about uptake of prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV (PMTCT) services. As FSW programs in Uganda do not provide PMTCT services, FSW would need to access these at general population clinics where they may receive multi-layered stigma derived from the combination of factors (e.g., selling sex while pregnant, being HIV positive and pregnant, being an HIV-positive sex worker). FSW, therefore, may encounter negative attitudes from multiple sources when seeking PMTCT services—service providers, other sex workers, other women accessing health services, and community members [31, 40‐42]. Additionally, our analysis may overestimate associations with using at least a moderately effective method of family planning because using such a method was relatively common. The age of these data highlight the infrequency with which biobehavioral surveys of female sex workers are conducted.

There are many opportunities for integration of sexual and reproductive health services with HIV services. In Kampala and elsewhere, a sizeable share of FSW experiencing STD symptoms obtain treatment directly from a pharmacy. Pharmacists can be trained to offer contraceptives, HIV testing, or HIV self-tests along with referrals to FSW-friendly health services [43, 44]. Similarly, drop-in center staff and outreach workers can similarly be trained to provide such services. As FSW on ART are already engaged with the healthcare system, every reproductive or other health service not provided to them during ART visits is a missed opportunity. Among FSW on ART in Kampala, 8.2% had active syphilis infection [9, 45]. For these women, each visit with an HIV treatment provider can be an opportunity to screen for and treat STD and discuss FP.