Methods
Identification of studies
Search | Search Term | Combination |
---|---|---|
1 | Infant/ or Child/ or Adolescent/ or Mothers/ or Fathers/ or Parents/ or Family/ or child.mp. or infant.mp. or mother.mp. or father.mp. or parent.mp. or adolescent.mp. or teenager.mp. or children.mp. | |
2 | (Family disorganization or Family disorganisation or hurried).mp. or (confusion adj2 hubbub).tw. or household disorganisation.mp. or household disorganization.mp. or (environmental chaos adj5 family).mp. or (environmental chaos adj5 home).mp. or (environmental chaos adj5 household).mp. or (environmental chaos adj5 house).mp. or (chaotic environment adj5 family).mp. or (chaotic environment adj5 home).mp. or (chaotic environment adj5 household).mp. or (chaotic environment adj5 house).mp. or (chaos adj5 family).mp. or (chaos adj5 home).mp. or (chaos adj5 household).mp. or (chaos adj5 house).mp. or (chaotic adj5 family).mp. or (chaotic adj5 home).mp. or (chaotic adj5 household).mp. or (chaotic adj5 house).mp. | |
3 | (Child health or Obesity or Overweight or Sleep or Diet or nutrition or “screen use” or Television or “family meals” or eating or Self-Control or self-regulation or Anxiety or Stress or “effortful control” or Attention or aggression or Decision Making or Resilience or family functioning or Parenting or Family Conflict or parental attitudes or Parenting or academic achievement or reading or literacy or mathematics or language or cognition or socio-emotional or social-emotional).mp. | |
4 | 1 and 2 and 3 | |
5 | Limit 4 to (english language and humans) |
Study selection
Inclusion criteria
Data extraction and synthesis
Outcome Category | Specific Outcomes Assessed |
---|---|
Cognitive and academic | Academic achievement/performance Cognitive ability/outcomes/development Executive function IQ Study skills Reading comprehension Intellectual functioning |
Socio-emotional and behavioural | Response to challenge and task persistence: • Response to academic challenge • Task persistence • Processing speed Behavioural and social: • Behavioural (including peer problems, conduct problems, impulsivity, aggression, anger, and prosocial behaviour) • Anxiety and stress • Social-emotional (including social problems, social competence, adjustment issues, and negative emotionality) • Attention/ADHD • Risk taking (including substance use, sexual activity, violence-related risk-taking, delinquency, and cheating) • Self-regulation and inhibitory control • Depression • Temperament • Future beliefs and aspirations • Empathy • Callous-unemotional traits and psychopathic characteristics |
Communication | Verbal/expressive vocabulary and non-verbal abilities Receptive vocabulary |
Parenting, family, and household functioning | Parenting: • Differential parenting • Parent-child closeness • Parenting – general • Parental self-efficacy • Parental mood • Harsh parenting • Discipline • Sibling relationships • Sleep-disturbing behaviours of family members • Parental reactions • Maternal attribution bias • Emotional availability • Child representation of family dysfunction Household characteristics and food security: • Food security • Family meal atmosphere |
Parent outcomes | Maternal executive function Parent diet/eating behaviours/weight status Maternal depression Maternal fatigue Maternal/parent sleep |
Hormone | Cortisol levels/profile Autonomic nervous system activity Developmental stability of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis activity Gut biomarkers Inflammatory profile |
Physical health, health behaviours, and communication disorders | Health/disease/disorder outcomes: • Child weight/weight status • HbA1c • Child health • Stuttering severity • Physical health symptoms Diet and Dietary behaviours: • Eating in the absence of hunger • Maternal feeding goals • Food-related behaviours Sleep: • Sleep • Sleep anxiety Other health behaviours/outcomes: • TV viewing behaviours in a laboratory setting • Maternal perceptions about physical activity |
Results
Study Characteristic | Na | |
---|---|---|
Type of study | Cross-sectional | 60 |
Longitudinal | 49 | |
Experimental/laboratory | 2 | |
Case-control | 1 | |
Sample Size | < 100 | 16 |
100- < 1000 | 72 | |
1000- < 10,000 | 22 | |
≥10,000 | 2 | |
Cohort/Study | TEDS | 12 |
FLP | 9 | |
Head Start Cohort | 6 | |
MCS +/− NESS | 5 | |
Pakistan cohort | 5 | |
Western Reserve Reading Project | 4 | |
Stand-alone Head Start Cohorts | 4 | |
Florida Twin Project OR from the Florida State Twin registry | 2 | |
SECCYD | 2 | |
SIBS | 2 | |
Early Alliance Trial | 1 | |
NAPLAN | 1 | |
BIDS | 1 | |
Early Growth and Development Study | 1 | |
ESM | 1 | |
FACES, 2006 | 1 | |
Food and Family Project | 1 | |
Fragile Families and Child Well-being Study | 1 | |
Guelph Family Health Study | 1 | |
Home Environment Comparison Study | 1 | |
PHDCN | 1 | |
Social and Educational Change (RISE) study | 1 | |
Wisconsin Twin Project | 1 | |
L-CID | 1 | |
SIESTA | 1 | |
Social and Character Development Research Program | 1 | |
Stand-alone studies/No study or cohort name | 46 | |
Context/Participants | Low income/rural | 34 |
Twins | 19 | |
Adopted children Child Diagnosis/Risk factor: | 1 | |
ADHD | 2 | |
Autism | 1 | |
Obesity | 2 | |
DRD4 risk | 1 | |
Stuttering | 1 | |
Sickle cell disease | 1 | |
Type 1 diabetes | 2 | |
Parent Diagnosis/Risk factor: | ||
Depression/ | 3 | |
Bipolar disorder | 2 | |
ADHD symptomology | 4 | |
Measure of Household Chaos Construct | CHAOS long form | 44 |
CHAOS short form | 42 | |
CHAOS adapted | 10 | |
Other – questionnaire and/or direct observation | 16 |
Methods of household chaos assessment
Outcomes of interest
Outcome of interest | N | Twin | Agea | Designb | Low ses | Measure of HC | Outcomes Assessed | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
C/O | L | |||||||
Asbury, 2006 [24] | 2017 | ✓ | 0 m, 4y, 7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator between non-shared environment variables and academic achievement | ||
Berry, 2016 [25] | 1235 | 2 m, 7 m, 2y, 3y, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Academic achievement; executive function | ||
Deater-Deckard, 2009 [3] | 302 | ✓ | 4-7y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS short form | IQ | |
Garrett-Peters, 2016 [26] | 1236 | 6, 15, 24, 36, 48, 58 m & kindergarten (USA) | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | HC as mediator between family income poverty and academic achievement in kindergarten | ||
Hanscombe, 2011 [27] | 2337 | ✓ | 9 & 12y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Academic performance | ||
Hart, 2007 [11] | 287 | ✓ | Kindergarten or 1st grade, then 1st or 2nd grade (USA) | ✓ | CHAOS short form | General cognitive ability; HC as mediator between shared environmental variance and cognitive ability | ||
Hur, 2015 [28] | 444 | 36-70 m | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as mediator between parent depressive symptoms and child cognitive outcomes | |||
Johnson, 2008 [7] | 455 | ✓ | mean 6.1 years | CHAOS short form | Woodcock score | |||
Pike, 2006 [29] | 5765 | ✓ | 0-3y, then 4y | CHAOS short form | Cognitive development | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2010 [30] | 203 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Academic achievement | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [31] | 101 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Learning at school | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [33] | 203 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Study skills | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [32] | 203 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Cognitive performance | |||
Taylor, 2014 [35] | ✓ | 7-13y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as mediator between respect for rules and reading comprehension | |||
Taylor, 2017 [34] | 269 | 9-16y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Reading comprehension | |||
Yarboi, 2017 [36] | 65 | 6-16y | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Intellectual functioning; academic achievement; executive functioning | |||
Response to Challenge & Task Persistence | ||||||||
Brown, 2008 [42] | 96 | 3-5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Response to academic challenge | ||
Fuller-Rowell, 2015 [50] | 256 | 9.2, 13.1, 17.5y | ✓ | CHAOS adapted | HC as a moderator between lower SES and task persistence | |||
Tomalski, 2017 [72] | 71 | 5.5 m | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Processing speed | |||
Behavioural & Social | ||||||||
Asbury, 2003 [37] | 4706 | ✓ | 4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as a mediator and moderator in the relationship between parenting and behavioural outcomes | ||
Asbury, 2006 [24] | 2017 | ✓ | 0 m, 4y, 7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator between non-shared environment variables and anxiety, hyperactivity, CP, and peer problems | ||
Berry, 2016 [25] | 1235 | 2 m, 7 m, 2y, 3y, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Social problems | ||
Bobbitt, 2016 [38] | 2447 | 3-4y, 3.5–4.5y (6 m follow-up) | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Behavioural problems; social skills | ||
Bridgett, 2013 [39] | 85 | 4 m | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator in relationship between maternal self-regulation and infant negative emotionality | ||
Brieant, 2017 [40] | 167 | 13-14y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator in relationship between parental EF and impulsivity and adolescent EF | |||
Brown, 2010 [41] | 123 | 4–7.5y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Child attention (assessed by both parent report and computer task) | ||
Calam, 2012 [43] | 48 | 2-10y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Child emotional difficulties | |||
Chatterjee, 2015 [44] | 929 | Mean 16.4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Substance use; sexual activity; and violence-related risk behaviours | |||
Chen, 2014 [45] | 149 | 3-7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Temperament-by-parenting interactionsd; HC as moderator | |||
Coldwell, 2006 [4] | 118 | 4-8y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Child problem behaviour; HC as a moderator in relationship between parenting and child behaviour | |||
Deater-Deckard, 2009 [3] | 302 | ✓ | 4-7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | CP | ||
Dumas, 2005 [10] (study 1) | 106 | 4-6y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Behaviour problems; social competence; anger; aggression; attention; ability to understand and respond to social cues | |||
Dumas, 2005 [10] (study 2) | 676 | 7-11y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Behaviour problems (caregiver and teacher report) | ||
Evans, 2005 [14] | 339 | Mean 9.2y at baseline | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form + 2 x questions on rituals and routines | HC as mediator in relationship between SES and socio-emotional adjustment | ||
Farbiash, 2014 [46] | 84 | 4y at follow-up | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as mediator in relationship between parental ADHD symptoms and preschool aggression | |||
Fisher, 2018 [80] | 390 | 8y at baseline, 15y at follow-up | ✓ | CHAOS long form (14 questions) | Psychopathic characteristics; CU; empathy; anxiety; aggression; delinquency; classroom climate quality as moderator of relationship between HC and adolescent outcomes | |||
Flouri, 2015 [48] | 10,086 | 3y, 5y, 7y | ✓ | 3 questions from CHAOS + 2 questions about bedtime and mealtimes | Occupational aspirations at age 7 years | |||
Flouri, 2017 [47] | 180 | 3y, 5y, 7y, 11y | ✓ | 3 x CHAOS questions | HC as mediator in relationship between low SES and CP in children with ADHD | |||
Fontaine, 2011 [49] | 9578 | 4y, 7y, 12y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | CP; CU traits | |||
Gould, 2017 [51] | 520 | ✓ | 6-15y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator of relationship between genes and development of ADHD | ||
Gregory, 2005 [52] | 6612 | 3y, 4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Anxiety; HC as mediator of relationship between sleep problems and anxiety | |||
Gunzenhauser, 2017 [53] | 263 | Mean 8.59y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Self-regulation | |||
Hannigan, 2017 [54] | 6646 | ✓ | 9y, 12y, 14, 16y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Depressive symptoms | ||
Hardaway, 2012 [55] | 731 | Mean 3.4y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Inhibitory control; problem behaviour; aggression | ||
Human, 2016 [56] | 261 | 13-16y at baseline (2-year follow-up) | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Depressive symptoms; perceived stress | |||
Hur, 2015 [28] | 444 | 36-70 m | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as mediator between parent depressive symptoms and child socio-emotional development, and behavioural self-regulation | |||
Jaffee, 2012 [57] | 6286 | ✓ | 9y, 12y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | CP; hyperactivity-inattention | ||
Kahn, 2016 [58] | 115 | Mean 13.97y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Moderated mediation analysis = Harsh parenting as a mediator in the relationship between parent CU traits and child CU traits, and then HC as a moderator of this relationship | |||
Kim-Spoon, 2017 [59] | 167 | 13-14y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator of relationship between parental control and social competence | |||
Lauharatanahirun, 2018 [81] | 167 | 13–15 years | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator between parental knowledge and insular risk processing | |||
Laurent, 2014 [60] | 200 | 9 m, 18 m, 27 m, 4.5y, 6y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Behaviour problems in adopted children | |||
Lemery-Chalfant, 2013 [61] | 807 | ✓ | Mean 7.93y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Genes as mediator in relationship between HC and child temperament (passive gene-environment); HC as moderator in relationship between genes and child temperament | ||
Martin, 2012 [6] | 1266 | 2.5y, 5y | ✓ | Questionnaire designed for study | Attention; aggression; delayed gratification; Mediating role of maternal warmth and provision of learning materials in the home on the relationship between lack of routines and delayed gratification | |||
Midouhas, 2013 [62] | 209 | 9 m, 3y, 5y, 7y | ✓ | 3 items from the CHAOS short form | CP in children with autism; HC as moderator of relationship between poverty and parenting, and psycopathology in children with autism | |||
Miller, 2017 [63] | 380 | Preschool (USA) | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Negative liability; emotion regulation | ||
Mills-Koonce, 2016 [64] | ~ 1292 | 2 m, 6 m, 15 m, 24 m, 36 m, first grade | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | CU; CP; empathy; HC as moderator in relationship between parenting and child behaviours; Maternal sensitivity and harsh parenting as mediators in relationship between HC and child behaviour | ||
Oliver, 2008 [65] | 285 | ✓ | 8-10y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator in relationship between within-pair differences in perceptions of the classroom environment and teacher report of less prosocial and more hyperactive behaviour, and greater conduct and peer problems | ||
Panico, 2014 [66] | 6572 | 3y, 5y | ✓ | 3 items from CHAOS | Behavioural outcomes | |||
Pike, 2006 [29] | 5765 | 0-3y, 4y | CHAOS short form | Behavioural outcomes | ||||
Raver, 2015 [67] | 1025 | Followed between 6 m and 58 m | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Ability to recognise and modulate negative emotions | ||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [31] | 101 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Attention | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [68] | 203 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | CP | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [32] | 203 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Internalising and externalising behaviours | |||
Shamama-tus-Sabah, 2011 [33] | 101 | 8-11y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Adjustment problems | |||
Shapero, 2013 [69] | 956 | Followed between birth and 15y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Changes in emotional and behavioural problems between childhood and adolescence | |||
Shelleby, 2014 [70] | 731 | 2-3y, 4-5y, 7.5–8.5y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator in relationship between income and emotional problems and CP | ||
Supplee, 2007 [71] | 120 | 2, 3, 4 & 5y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Externalising behaviours; Maternal monitoring as moderator in relationship between HC and externalising behaviours | ||
Towe-Goodman, 2011 [73] | 636 | Infant, toddler, 3y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as moderator in relationship between interparental aggression in toddlerhood and the development of child attention skills and early childhood behaviour problems at age 3 years, in low-income families | ||
Tucker, 2015 [74] | 325 | Mean 15.71y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Adolescents’ future beliefs; Mother’s hostility as moderator in relationship between HC and adolescents’ future beliefs | |||
Tucker, 2018 [82] | 238 | Followed between 10th grade (mean 15.59y) and 12th grade | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Problematic substance use, depression; HC as moderator in relationship between hostile parenting and depression | ||
Valiente, 2007 [75] | 188 | 7-12y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Effortful control; externalising behaviours | |||
Vernon-Feagans, 2016 [76] | 1145 | 2, 6, 15, 24, 48, & 60 months | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Regulatory behaviours in kindergarten; Parenting and executive function as mediators of the relationship between HC and behaviours | ||
Vilsaint, 2013 [77] | 364 | 2y, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Internalising & externalising behaviours | ||
Vrijhof, 2018 [83] | 201 | ✓ | 34-66 m | ✓ | CHAOS long from | Effortful control; cheating behaviour | ||
Wang, 2012 [78] | 304 | ✓ | Mean 6.07y, 7.15y, & 8.30y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator in the genetic link between attention regulation and externalising behaviours | ||
Wilkinson, 2013 [79] | ~ 8800 | ✓ | 2, 6, 15, 24, 48, & 60 months | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as moderator in relationship between genes and depressive symptoms (Gene × Environment interaction) | ||
Asbury, 2005 [84] | 2223 | ✓ | 4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Verbal and non-verbal abilities; HC as moderator in the heritability of verbal and non-verbal abilities | ||
Berry, 2016 [25] | 1235 | 2 m, 7 m, 2y, 3y, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Receptive vocab | ||
Johnson, 2008 [7] | 455 | ✓ | mean 6.1 years | CHAOS short form | Expressive vocab and phonological awareness | |||
Martin, 2012 [6] | 1266 | 2.5y, 5y | ✓ | Questions designed for study | Receptive vocab; Mediating role of provision of learning materials in the home on the relationship between lack of routines and receptive vocab | |||
Petrill, 2004 [23] | ✓ | 3 & 4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Verbal and non-verbal abilities; HC as mediator in relationship between shared environment and verbal and non-verbal scores | |||
Vernon-Feagans, 2012 [85] | 1145 | 2, 6, 15, 24, & 36 m | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/observation | Receptive and expressive language | ||
Parenting | ||||||||
Atzaba-Poria, 2008 [86] | 344 | 4-5y and an older sibling aged <=8y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Differential parenting | |||
Barnes, 2014 [87] | 24,610 | 3y | ✓ | 3 questions from CHAOS | Parent/child conflict & closeness; home learning environment; parenting | |||
Chen, 2014 [45] | 149 | 3-7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Temperament-by-parenting interactionsd; HC as a moderator | |||
Coldwell, 2006 [4] | 118 | 4-8y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Parenting | |||
Corapci, 2002 [88] | 57 | 12-14 m | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Parenting; Parental self-efficacy and parent negative mood as mediators in relationship between HC and parenting | |||
Deater-Deckard, 2012 [89] | 147 | 3-7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as a moderator of maternal EF, which itself was assessed as a moderator in the relationship between child CP and harsh parenting | |||
Dumas, 2005 [10] (study 1) | 106 | 4-6y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Parental discipline, and accuracy and efficiency in a co-operative parent-child interactional task | |||
Kretschmer, 2009 [91] | 118 | 4-8y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Sibling relationships; Parenting as a mediator and moderator in the relationship between HC and sibling relationships | |||
Mokrova, 2010 [92] | 319 | 7y (group 1) & 10y (group 2) | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator and moderator in relationships between maternal and paternal ADHD symptoms and parenting | |||
Nelson, 2009 [93] | 101 | 7y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Parental supportive and nonsupportive responses to child | |||
Pike, 2016 [94] | 106 | Siblings aged 4–8 years at baseline & 9–13 years at follow-up | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Siblings’ perceptions of mothering and fathering | |||
Spilsbury, 2017 [96] | 26 | 11-12y | ✓d | CHAOS long form | Sleep-disturbing behaviours of family members | |||
Valiente, 2007 [75] | 188 | 7-12y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Positive and negative reactions to child’s negative emotions | |||
Vernon-Feagans, 2012 [85] | 1123 | 2, 6, 15, 24, & 36 m | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Parenting as a mediator in the relationship between HC and language development | ||
Wang, 2013 [97] | 160 | 3-7y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | HC as a moderator in relationship between maternal attribution bias (e.g. whether they attribute child misbehaviour to the child’s intentions and dismiss situational factors) and parenting behaviour | |||
Whitesell, 2015 [98] | 100 | 1, 3, 6, 9, & 12 m | ✓ | DISCORD - an observer reported measure of HC | SES; life events; co-parenting; emotional availability at bedtime | |||
Wirth, 2017 [99] | 84 | 7-13y | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator in relationship between children’s ADHD symptoms and inadequate parenting | ||||
Zvara, 2014 [100] | 962 | 2, 6, 15, 24, 60 months & 1st grade | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Children’s representations of family dysfunction from drawings; mediating role of parenting in relationship between HC and family dysfunction | ||
Household Characteristics and Food Security | ||||||||
Fiese, 2016 [90] | 221 | Elementary school (USA) | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Food security | ||
Martin-Biggers, 2018 [101] | 550 | 2-5y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Family meals; food availability/security; family meal atmosphere | |||
Pinard, 2015 [95] | 252 | 0-18y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Food security | ||
Deater-Deckard, 2012 [12] | 153 | 33-88 me | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Maternal EF; SES as moderator of relationship between HC and maternal EF | |||
MacRae, 2017 [102] | 44 | 1 ½ - 5ye | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Parent fat intake and cortisol levels | |||
Madigan, 2017 [103] | 501 | 2-54 me | ✓ | Adapted version of the HOME scale | Maternal depression trajectories | |||
Martin-Biggers, 2018 [101] | 550 | 2-5y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Maternal eating behaviours; weight status; health status | |||
Thomas, 2016 [104] | 42 | 32wkse | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Maternal depression, fatigue, and sleep | |||
Whitesell, 2018 [105] | 167 | 1, 3, 6, 9, 12 m | ✓ | DISCORD | Parent sleep | |||
Blair, 2013 [106] | 1292 | 2, 7, 24, & 36 mo, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Cortisol and ANS activity | ||
Chen, 2010 [107] | 50 | 9-18y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator in the relationship between low SES and cortisol profiles | ||
Doom, 2018 [112] | 242 | 35–62, 38–85, 84-122 m | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Diurnal cortisol levels in response to social stress test | ||
Laurent, 2014 [60] | 200 | 9 m, 18 m, 27 m, 4.5y, 6y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Developmental stability of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis activity | |||
Lumeng, 2014 [108] | 331 | 3-4y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Morning cortisol levels | ||
Miller, 2013 [109] | 34 | 3-4y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Gut biomarkers | ||
O’Brien, 2013 [110] | 135 | 18-66y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Stress | |||
Schreier, 2014 [111] | 244 | 13-16y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Inflammatory profile | |||
Health/Disease/Disorder Outcomes | ||||||||
Appelhans, 2014 [113] | 103 | 6-13y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HC as mediator in relationship between sleep duration and child weight | ||
Chae, 2016 [114] | 125 | Mean 12.6y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HbA1c | |||
Dush, 2013 [115] | 3288 | 3y, 5y | ✓ | ✓ | Interview/ observation | Child health | ||
Khatiwada, 2018 [118] | 401 | Infants; followed during first 12 mo | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Weight status | |||
Kraft, 2014 [117] | 69 | Mean 3.7y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Stuttering severity | |||
Levin, 2013 [116] | 104 | 1-13y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | HbA1c | |||
Lumeng, 2014 [108] | 331 | 3-4y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Overweight | ||
Martin-Biggers, 2018 [101] | 550 | 2-5y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Health status; weight status | |||
Tucker, 2018 [82] | 238 | Followed between 10th grade (mean at baseline 15.59y) and 12th grade | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Physical health symptoms; HC as moderator in relationship between hostile parenting and physical health symptoms | ||
Diet & Dietary Behaviours | ||||||||
Asta, 2016 [119] | 209 | 21, 27, & 33 m | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS (not specified) | Eating in the absence of hunger | ||
Goulding, 2015 [120] | 287 | 4-8y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Maternal feeding goals | ||
Martin-Biggers, 2018 [101] | 550 | 2-5y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Food-related behaviours | |||
Sleep | ||||||||
Bartel, 2016 [121] | 1402 | 12-19y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Sleep | |||
Billows, 2009 [122] | 217 | 13-18y | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Sleep | |||
Boles, 2017 [13] | 72 | Mean 4.7y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Sleep; HC as a mediator in relationship between behaviour and sleep outcomes. | ||
Gregory, 2005 [52] | 6612 | 3y, 4y | ✓ | CHAOS short form | Sleep; HC as mediator relationship between sleep problems and anxiety | |||
Spilsbury, 2017 [96] | 26 | 11-12y | ✓d | CHAOS long form | Sleep | |||
Whitesell, 2018 [105] | 167 | 1, 3, 6, 9, 12 m | ✓ | DISCORD | Sleep | |||
Other Health Behaviours/Outcomes | ||||||||
Brown, 2010 [123] | 70 | 4–7.5y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | TV viewing behaviours in a laboratory setting | ||
Pesch, 2015 [124] | 278 | 4-8y | ✓ | ✓ | CHAOS long form | Maternal perceptions about physical activity. |
Cognitive and academic
Socio-emotional and behavioural
Communication
Parenting, and family and household functioning
Parent outcomes
Hormones
Physical health, health behaviours and communication disorders
Mediation and moderation analyses
Study | HC as mediator | HC as moderator |
---|---|---|
Asbury, 2003 [37] | HC did not mediate the relationship between parenting and behavioural outcomes. | HC significantly moderated the relationship between (1) differential harsh parental discipline and differential CP, and (2) differential negative parental feelings and anxiety, hyperactivity, and CP. That is, the relationship between NSE influences (i.e. differential parenting) and behavioural outcomes were stronger in high chaos homes. |
Asbury, 2006 [24] | HC moderated the relationship between: (1) discordant harsh discipline and CP [increase in CP], (2) discordant negative feelings and CP [increase in CP], (3) discordant parental negative feelings and academic achievement [achievement decreased], and (4) instructive parent-child communication and anxiety [anxiety increased] (where instructive communication including things like correcting child’s grammar) | |
Boles, 2017 [13] | Children with higher scores for emotional and behaviour problems were more likely to have higher bedtime resistance, but higher levels of HC may account for this relationship; HC associated with bedtime resistance significantly mediated the relationship between Behavioural and Emotional Screen System and bedtime resistance. | |
Bridgett, 2013 [39] | HC mediated the effects of maternal self-regulation on infant frustration/distress to limitations. | |
Brieant, 2017 [40] | Parent EF significantly predicted changes over time in adolescent EF, with this association contingent on levels HC, such that a stronger relationship was observed in the presence of greater HC. | |
Chen, 2010 [107] | HC partially mediated the relationship between SES and daily cortisol output. | |
Chen, 2014 [45] | HC moderated the relationship between harsher maternal negativity and child maladjustment in children who had low levels of effortful control. HC did not moderate any other temperament-by-parenting interactions. | |
Coldwell, 2006 [4] | In a minority of cases, HC was found to moderate the role between parenting and child behaviour, whereby HC exacerbated the effect of poorer quality parenting on problem behaviour. | |
Deater-Deckard, 2012 [89] | Maternal EF moderated the relationship between child CP and harsh parenting, so that this relationship was only significant in mothers with poorer EF. Further, this moderating effect of EF was further moderated by HC, so that the effect was particularly strong in the presence of low HC, but not high HC. | |
Evans, 2005 [14] | The adverse effects of poverty on socioemotional adjustment were shown to be mediated by HC. | |
Farbiash, 2014 [46] | HC was found to significantly mediate the relationship between paternal (but not maternal) ADHD symptoms and children’s aggression in the preschool years. | |
Flouri, 2017 [47] | HC did not mediate the relationship between low SES and CP in children with ADHD | |
Fuller-Rowell, 2015 [50] | Early HC moderated relationship between poverty and task persistence in later adolescence. | |
Garrett-Peters, 2016 [26] | In the presence of household disorganisation (but not instability), income poverty was no longer directly related to academic achievement. Income was related to disorganisation, however, which in turn was associated with lower academic achievement. | |
Gould, 2017 [51] | HC did not moderate the relationship between genes and development of ADHD. | |
Gregory, 2005 [52] | HC partially mediated the relationship between sleep problems and child anxiety, with HC accounting for ~ 30% of the association. | |
Hart, 2007 [11] | HC mediated the relationship between shared environmental variance and longitudinal stability of cognitive ability in early childhood. | |
Hur, 2015 [28] | HC mediated relationship between parental depressive symptoms and mother-reported social skills of child. | |
Kahn, 2016 [58] | Hostile parenting mediated the relationship between parent and adolescent CU, but only in the presence of high HC. Harsh parenting explained intergenerational similarity in CU traits, and HC exacerbated this relationship. | |
Kim-Spoon, 2017 [59] | High parental control predicted better neural cognitive control in adolescents living in low HC contexts. Poor neural cognitive control was associated with reduced social competence 1-year later (after controlling for social competence at baseline), but this relationship was only significant in high HC contexts. HC was shown to undermine positive associations between parental control and adolescent neural cognitive control and exacerbated the negative association between poor neural cognitive control and social competence development. | |
Lauharatanahirun, 2018 [81] | HC moderated the relationship between adolescent-report of parental knowledge/parental monitoring and adolescent insular risk processing, which has been shown to precede risk-adverse choices, whereby it was only present in the presence of low HC. | |
Lemery-Chalfant, 2013 [61] | Heritability of children’s temperament was moderated by HC, meaning that effortful control and surgency were more heritable in high HC contexts. | |
Midouhas, 2013 [62] | Autism was associated with higher rates of psychopathology over time, and family poverty was associated with emotional and CP (psychopathology); however, home organisation did not moderate the relationship between family poverty and psychopathology. | |
Mills-Koonce, 2016 [64] | HC did not moderate the relationship between parenting and child behaviours. | |
Mokrova, 2010 [92] | Mother’s ADHD symptoms were positively associated with inconsistent discipline and non-supportive responses to child’s negative emotions; this relationship was mediated by HC. Father’s ADHD symptoms were associated with low involvement; HC mediated this relationship. | Father’s ADHD symptoms were associated with inconsistent discipline; this relationship was moderated by HC. |
Oliver, 2008 [65] | HC moderated the relationship between within-pair differences in perceptions of the classroom environment and teacher report of less prosocial and more hyperactive behaviour, and greater conduct and peer problems. Specifically, associations between differential classroom environment and CP were greater for children in more chaotic homes. | |
Petrill, 2004 [23] | HC partially mediated an independent and significant portion of the shared environment for verbal and nonverbal and PARCA scores at ages 3 and 4 years. HC was a significant mediator even when controlling for SES. | |
Shelleby, 2014 [70] | Significant direct association between income and emotional problems and CP; HC was a significant mediator in the relationship between income and emotional problems. | |
Taylor, 2014 [35] | HC mediated relationship between respect for rules and increased reading comprehension, even after controlling for income. | |
Towe-Goodman, 2011 [73] | In a low-income sub-group, HC was found to moderate the relationship between interparental aggression in toddlerhood and the development of child attention skills and early childhood behaviour problems at age 3 years. In low-income families with low HC, there was a significant association between greater interparental aggression and increases 3-year ADHD symptoms, but this relationship was not significant in low-income, high HC families. | |
Tucker, 2018 [82] | HC moderated the effect of hostile parenting on adolescents’ depression 2 years later, so that depression was exacerbated in the context of high HC. HC did not moderate the relationship between parenting and physical health and problematic substance use. | |
Wang, 2012 [78] | HC moderated the genetic variance and covariance between externalising problems and attention regulation, with the genetic influences stronger in HC contexts; however, higher levels of HC attenuated the genetic association between externalising problems and attention regulation. | |
Wang, 2013 [97] | The relationship between maternal attribution bias and parenting behaviour were stronger in more chaotic environments; the moderating effect of HC was particularly strong for internal attribution bias. | |
Wilkinson, 2013 [79] | Depressive symptoms at age 12 were significantly heritable, and HC and parenting style at age 9 years moderated this association. | |
Wirth, 2017 [99] | The relationships between ADHD and positive parenting, corporal punishment, and inconsistent discipline were somewhat mediated by HC. As such, high HC was associated with specific parenting dimensions in families with children with ADHD. |
Study | Relationship between HC and outcome mediated | Relationship between HC and outcome moderated |
---|---|---|
Asbury, 2005 [84] | There was greater group heritability for verbal ability, but not non-verbal ability, in early childhood within the context of higher HC. | |
Berry, 2016 [25] | Relationship between increased household disorganisation and decreased cognitive and social outcomes was somewhat moderated by childcare hours (i.e. greater childcare hours attenuated the relationship) | |
Brown, 2008 [42] | Sleep problems partially mediated the relationship between HC and hopeless/helpless responses to academic challenge. | |
Corapci, 2002 [88] | Overall neither parental mood nor self-efficacy was found to mediate the relationship between HC and parenting. | |
Deater-Deckard, 2012 [12] | The relationship between HC and maternal EF was moderated by SES, meaning the adverse effects of HC on maternal EF may be particularly important within socioeconomically distressed contexts. | |
Fisher, 2018 [80] | The quality of classroom climate across 3 years of elementary school was not found to moderate the relationship between HC and adolescent outcomes. | |
Khatiwada, 2018 [118] | HC was positively associated with weight status at 12 months of age; however, this relationship was not mediated by breastfeeding, sleep, or screen time. | |
Kretschmer, 2009 [91] | The relationship between HC and sibling relationship quality was mediated by parenting, including maternal warmth and paternal harsh discipline. | The relationship between HC and sibling relationship quality was moderated by maternal harsh discipline. |
Lemery-Chalfant, 2013 [61] | Lower HC was associated with higher effortful control in children, and this association was genetically mediated. | |
Martin, 2012 [6] | Lack of routines was associated with lower receptive vocab and delayed gratification. In homes with the TV usually on, children had greater aggression scores and attention problems. The association between routines and receptive vocab was partially mediated by provision of learning materials. The association between lack of routines and delayed gratification was not mediated by maternal warmth or provision of learning materials, suggesting routines in and of themselves were associated with development of early self-regulation. | |
Miller, 2017 [63] | HC was negatively associated with emotion regulation, but this relationship was not moderated by cortisol levels. The relationship between routines and emotion regulation was moderated by cortisol level, meaning that lack of routines was more strongly associated with poor emotion regulation in children with lower cortisol output. | |
Mills-Koonce, 2016 [64] | Maternal sensitivity and harsh parenting mediated the relationship between HC and child behaviours. | |
Supplee, 2007 [71] | Maternal report of HC was associated with children’s externalising behaviour at age 4 years, even after controlling for SES and ethnicity. | HC was positively associated with teacher report of externalising problems at school at age 5.5 years. Maternal monitoring was not found to moderate the effects of HC on externalising behaviour. |
Tucker, 2015 [74] | HC predicted less positive adolescent beliefs about mastery, future obstacles, and having a successful career; mother’s hostility moderated the relationship between HC and future obstacles and stress about the transition to emerging adulthood. | |
Vernon-Feagans, 2012 [85] | Household disorganisation was associated with variance in receptive and expressive language; parenting partially mediated this relationship. | |
Vernon-Feagans, 2016 [76] | Disorganisation in the home was indirectly associated with behavioural regulation through intermediate impacts on parenting behaviours and children’s early executive function skills. | |
Zvara, 2014 [100] | Cumulative family disorganisation, but not cumulative family instability, was found to have a significant indirect on children’s representation of family dysfunction through parenting behaviours. As such, the proximal effects of daily disorganisation appeared to outweigh the effects of periodic instability overtime. |