Introduction
Tobacco smoking (TS) causes more than 480,000 deaths in the United States (US) by contributing to many diseases, including cancer, lung diseases, cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disorders [
1]. Although there has been a steady decline in cigarette smoking among adults in the US from 42 to 14% between 1964 and 2019 [
1,
2], the increasing use of alternative tobacco products like electronic cigarettes (e-Cigs) poses a new threat to public health. E-Cigs were first introduced in the US market in 2007, and their popularity has risen since [
3]. Vaping, the common term for smoking e-Cigs, has increased significantly in adult and adolescent populations [
4,
5]. Nicotine is delivered in aerosol form by e-Cig devices produced from a vaporizing liquid. JUUL is a recently developed portable e-Cig device that physically resembles a universal serial bus (USB) flash drive, a feature unique from other e-Cig products in the market [
6,
7], which currently is one of the most popular e-Cig brands in the US. Although JUUL e-Cig was introduced to help adult heavy smokers quit smoking or as a less harmful alternative to TS, it is also very popular in adolescents. JUUL e-Cig consists of a liquid & heating coil-containing pod and a rechargeable battery. The nicotine in the JUUL-pod is claimed to be salt-based instead of the free base found in other e-Cig products [
7,
8], which could facilitate the vapor inhalation process and generate higher nicotine concentrations [
9]. This could make JUUL more harmful to its users than other e-Cigs. Rigorous research is required to elucidate the health effects of JUUL e-Cigs.
Stroke is another major cause of morbidity and mortality in the US, causing death every 4 min [
10]. Stroke is primarily of 2 types: ischemic and hemorrhagic. Ischemic stroke comprises 87% of all strokes and is characterized by the interruption of blood flow to the brain [
10]. Smoking is one of the most common comorbid conditions that can increase the risk and worsen the outcome of an ischemic stroke event [
11]. Our lab has previously shown that exposure to nicotine and smoking can worsen brain injury and neurological outcomes [
12,
13] and decrease brain glucose transport [
14] and utilization [
15] in ischemic stroke. The blood–brain barrier (BBB) is an integral part of the brain neurovascular unit and plays a vital role in maintaining normal brain physiology and ionic and nutrient balance. BBB disruption, inflammation, and oxidative stress are major pathological hallmarks of ischemic stroke [
16]. The deleterious role of TS on BBB function, inflammation, and oxidative stress has been depicted in preclinical studies [
12,
17‐
19]. Exposure to nicotine-containing JUUL e-Cigs is predicted to adversely affect the ischemic brain, leading to a poor clinical prognosis.
Some studies have investigated the cerebrovascular effects of e-Cigs [
12,
15,
20], but very few [
21] have specifically addressed the toxic effects of JUUL e-Cigs on the brain. Ramirez et al. have shown that short-term JUUL e-Cig exposure can increase the risk of thrombotic events [
22]. To our knowledge, no study has yet addressed the effects of JUUL e-Cigs on the cerebrovascular system. In this study, we have investigated the impact of short-term JUUL e-Cig exposure on brain injury, BBB tight junction (TJ) proteins, and inflammatory and oxidative stress markers in ischemic stroke in direct comparison with TS.
Discussion
JUUL e-Cigs have become extremely popular recently, and studies are needed to elucidate their possible toxic effects on the cerebrovascular system. In this study, we have investigated the impact of short-term JUUL exposure on ischemic brain injury, BBB TJ proteins, and inflammatory and antioxidative markers compared with TS in mice. To our knowledge, this is the first study that evaluated cerebrovascular toxicities of JUUL with a side-by-side comparison with TS using a preclinical model of ischemic stroke.
We have used a well-established smoking/vaping exposure model for this study [
12,
20,
23,
24]. Plasma nicotine and cotinine level in mice after 2 weeks of TS and JUUL exposure were comparable to previously published in vivo studies [
23,
25‐
27]. Importantly, these concentrations were also reflective of human cigarette smokers [
23,
28]. We found higher plasma nicotine and cotinine concentrations in TS-exposed mice than JUUL-exposed mice, consistent with published studies in our laboratory and others involving TS and e-Cigs [
23,
25‐
27]. Further, nicotine to cotinine metabolism was also reduced in plasma of JUUL-exposed mice than that of TS. One possible explanation of this could be the formation of nicotyrine by the gradual oxidation of e-liquids exposed to air. Nicotyrine inhibits CYP2A enzymes in the lungs and liver, thus could inhibit nicotine metabolism to cotinine by CYP2A6 [
29].
The weights of the mice were drastically reduced after two weeks of TS exposure. Significant weight reduction was also observed with JUUL exposure. It has been widely reported that nicotine and TS can reduce body weight in preclinical [
30,
31] and clinical studies [
32,
33]. Vaping was also shown to decrease body weight [
34,
35]. In our study, TS-exposed mice showed hyperactivity in the open field test. It is consistent with other studies which showed that short-term TS exposure increases physical activity in rodents compared to control [
36]. Interestingly, mice exposed to long-term (10 months) of TS [
36] or heavy human smokers [
37,
38] displayed reduced physical activity, suggesting a differential effect induced by acute vs. chronic nicotine exposure.
Our study found that both JUUL and TS can increase brain injury after ischemic stroke. TS exposure also worsened brain swelling and neurological functions. This result is consistent with our group's previous study, which showed that TS and e-Cig (Blu) exposure [
12] could worsen ischemic brain injury. We also showed that acute administration of nicotine and nicotine-containing TS extract increases brain edema/swelling and infarct ratio after MCAO [
13]. Other researchers have demonstrated that exposure to nicotine or TS can worsen ischemic brain damage in rodents [
19,
39,
40].
JUUL or TS exposure did not cause any significant change in our study's plasma concentration of the inflammatory marker IL-6. However, we found that ischemic stroke increases the plasma level of IL-6. Plasma IL-6 concentration 24 h after ischemic stroke was the highest in TS pre-exposed mice, although no significant difference was found among the groups. Per our findings, IL-6 has been identified as a prognostic marker for ischemic stroke, as it was correlated with worsened ischemic brain injury and outcome in clinical [
41‐
44] and preclinical [
45,
46] studies. Thrombomodulin is a natural anticoagulant [
47], which exerts a protective effect in acute ischemic stroke by inhibiting coagulation, fibrinolysis, and inflammation, stabilizing barrier function, and increasing blood flow [
48]. We found decreased plasma thrombomodulin concentrations after ischemic stroke, but no significant effects of JUUL or TS- pre-exposure were observed after MCAO. The serum concentration of soluble thrombomodulin decreased at the acute stage and increased after six months of ischemic stroke onset, as shown in a clinical study [
49]. In contrast, plasma thrombomodulin was higher in a clinical study by Zhang et al., which could be due to a small sample number [
50]. In another study, expression of endothelial thrombomodulin was decreased in the ischemic core region but increased in the peri-infarct area, compared to the contralateral side [
51].
Disruption of the BBB is one of the key pathophysiological features of ischemic stroke, contributing to ischemic brain injury and neurological disturbances [
52]. Ischemic stroke causes disruptions in the TJ proteins at the BBB [
53]. Claudin-5 is a crucial BBB TJ protein responsible for increased paracellular permeability in experimental stroke settings if disrupted [
52,
54]. Occludin regulates functional integrity and paracellular permeability of the BBB [
55,
56], while ZO-1 connects transmembrane TJ proteins to the actin cytoskeleton [
57]. TS and e-Cig exposure decreased the expression of ZO-1 in an in vitro model of BBB [
12]. Prasad et al. found no significant change in ZO-1 and occludin expression after 2 weeks of TS exposure. However, 4 weeks of TS exposure decreased the expression of those TJ proteins [
58]. Our study did not observe any significant change in the expression of the TJ proteins (ZO-1, claudin-5, and occludin) after two weeks of JUUL or TS exposure. This could be due to the inherent difference between in vitro and in vivo systems and the amount & duration of exposure. Our western blot and immunofluorescence studies showed reduced ZO-1 and occludin in the contralateral hemisphere by JUUL and TS exposure.
Interestingly, only JUUL exposure reduced occludin expression in the ipsilateral hemisphere. Claudin-5 expression was not substantially affected by JUUL and TS exposure, as observed in our study. We observed the harmful effects of JUUL or TS on BBB TJ protein expression only after ischemic stroke, which implies that adding another insult accentuates the harmful effects caused by JUUL or TS exposure on the BBB. Studies investigating the impact of TS and/or e-Cig on BBB and TJ proteins in acute ischemic stroke have been scarce. Acute exposure to TS extract worsened BBB disruption after the ischemia-like condition in an in vitro study [
59]. Sladojevic et al. showed that claudin-5 expression in the ipsilateral brain hemisphere was decreased after MCAO, but no change of this protein in the contralateral brain hemisphere was observed [
60].
Similarly, ZO-1 and occludin expression in the ischemic cortex was significantly decreased in a photothrombotic stroke model; however, their expression was unchanged in the contralateral hemisphere [
53]. By contrast, researchers found BBB damage in the contralateral brain hemisphere in an in vivo model of sub-acute ischemic stroke [
61]. This change in the contralateral brain was associated with reactive astrocytes and microglia in that hemisphere, indicating an inflammatory response [
61]. Interestingly, significant changes in brain activity and functional connectivity in the contralateral brain hemisphere in acute ischemic stroke have been reported, linked with functional recovery [
62]. The reduction of TJ proteins' expression in the contralateral hemisphere by TS or JUUL pre-exposure, as observed in our study, could be due to an enhanced release of inflammatory mediators (cytokines, chemokines, matrix metalloproteinases—MMPs, and vascular endothelial growth factor—VEGF) in the bloodstream from the ischemic hemisphere, which may create a profound effect on the non-ischemic hemisphere. The mechanisms of these observed changes will be the subject of future investigation, with focused experiments measuring astroglia and microglia markers in both hemispheres. Overall, these findings bear significance as by reducing the otherwise unchanged TJ proteins in the contralateral hemisphere, the whole ischemic brain could be indirectly affected, leading to worsened brain damage after acute ischemic stroke. One limitation of the current study is that we have measured TJ protein expression at the BBB with western blot using total brain tissue instead of studying the expression of those proteins in isolated brain microvessels. Therefore, the reported values may slightly differ from TJs proteins expression levels directly measured from purified brain microvessels. However, this procedure has been previously used for similar studies [
12,
24,
58] to assess the cerebrovascular impact of smoking on BBB TJs expression under diseased conditions (e.g., traumatic brain injury—TBI) and the protective effect of potential countermeasures.
Oxidative stress and inflammation play a vital role in the pathobiology of ischemic stroke. Nrf2 is a nuclear transcription factor regulating the cellular antioxidative response system. Nrf2 has also been shown to play an essential role in TS-mediated BBB toxicity and ischemic stroke. Nrf2 was previously shown to be downregulated by chronic TS and/or e-Cig exposure in vitro and/or in vivo [
12,
58]. However, we did not observe any significant change after 2 weeks of JUUL or TS exposure. Nrf2 was upregulated in tMCAO studies [
63] and also exerted protective effects against ischemic brain damage [
63,
64]. Dang et al. demonstrated cellular expression of Nrf2 in ischemic rat brains by double immunofluorescence staining [
65]. They found enhanced Nrf2 expression in the ipsilateral penumbra region in both neurons and glial cells (astrocytes, microglia). However, Nrf2 was significantly induced only in neurons in the contralateral brain hemisphere. In our western blot studies, Nrf2 expression was significantly decreased in the contralateral brain after MCAO with JUUL or TS pre-exposure. In immunofluorescence studies, we found a similar reduction of Nrf2 in the contralateral brain by JUUL or TS exposure. However, immunofluorescence studies also showed a significant reduction of Nrf2 in the ipsilateral brain regions by JUUL or TS exposure, contrasting the western blot results. Using whole brain tissue for western blot may have contributed to the contradictory results. Kaisar et al. also observed that e-Cig or TS exposure decreases brain Nrf2 expression after ischemic stroke [
12].
By reducing the antioxidative and cytoprotective actions of Nrf2, JUUL and TS could worsen the ischemic brain damage and neurological outcome. ICAM-1 is an inflammatory marker that helps in leukocyte infiltration in response to an ischemic event [
66]. We did not observe any significant change in ICAM-1 expression after JUUL or TS exposure. Prasad et al. also observed no significant change in ICAM-1 expression after 2 weeks of TS exposure [
58]. Contrastingly, TS extract increased the expression of ICAM-1 in hCMEC/D3 BBB endothelial cells [
67]. In another study, 2 weeks of TS and e-Cig exposure increased brain ICAM-1 expression [
12]. Higher endothelial ICAM-1 expression was observed in the brain after acute ischemic stroke in clinical [
66,
68,
69], and preclinical studies [
69‐
71]. In our study, ICAM-1 was significantly increased in the ischemic brain hemisphere of TS pre-exposed mice, but not in JUUL-exposed mice. This increase in inflammation could be one of the mechanisms of TS-mediated exacerbated ischemic brain injury and neurological damage. The unchanged ICAM-1 expression after only JUUL or TS exposure could be due to differences between in vitro and in vivo systems and duration of exposure, as explained earlier. The increase of ICAM-1 by TS exposure in the ipsilateral brain can also be explained by the observed decrease of Nrf2 in the same region in immunofluorescent studies. Nrf2 and its downstream pathway exert protective effects against inflammation by regulating anti-inflammatory gene expression and inhibiting inflammation [
72]. Overexpression of Nrf2 has been shown to inhibit TNF-α-induced ICAM-1 expression in human retinal pigment epithelial cells treated with lycopene [
73]. On the other hand, knockdown of Nrf2 enhanced brain ICAM-1 expression in a mouse model of traumatic brain injury [
74]. This inhibitory role of Nrf2 on ICAM-1 can explain the overexpression of the latter in the ischemic brain.
TS exerted more cerebrovascular toxicity than JUUL, as observed in some of our abovementioned findings, which could be due to the higher nicotine concentration in TS-exposed mice. Further, TS has thousands of toxic chemicals, which could also be responsible for the enhanced toxicities. In the future, we would like to investigate the cerebrovascular effects of 4 weeks of JUUL e-Cig exposure with higher nicotine (5%) concentration and compare it to TS exposure.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.