Anzeige
Erschienen in:
20.12.2021 | Reports of Original Investigations
Clinical evaluation and ancillary testing for the diagnosis of death by neurologic criteria: a cross-sectional survey of Canadian intensivists
Erschienen in: Canadian Journal of Anesthesia/Journal canadien d'anesthésie | Ausgabe 3/2022
Einloggen, um Zugang zu erhaltenAbstract
Purpose
Trust in the deceased organ donation process relies on the expectation that the diagnosis of death by neurologic criteria (DNC) is accurate and reliable. The objective of this study was to assess the perceptions and approaches to DNC diagnosis among Canadian intensivists.
Methods
We conducted a self-administered, online, cross-sectional survey of Canadian intensivists. Our sampling frame included all intensivists practicing in Canadian institutions. Results are reported using descriptive statistics.
Results
Among 550 identified intensivists, 249 (45%) completed the survey. Respondents indicated they would be comfortable diagnosing DNC based on clinical criteria alone in cases where there is movement in response to stimulation (119/248; 48%); inability to evaluate upper/lower extremity responses (84/249; 34%); spontaneous peripheral movement (76/249; 31%); inability to evaluate both oculocephalic and oculo-caloric reflexes (40/249; 16%); presence of high cervical spinal cord injury (40/249; 16%); and within 24 hr of hypoxemic-ischemic brain injury (38/247; 15%). Most respondents agreed that an ancillary test should always be conducted when a complete clinical evaluation is impossible (225/241; 93%); when there is possibility of a residual sedative effect (216/242; 89%); when the mechanism for brain injury is unclear (172/241; 71%); and if isolated brainstem injury is suspected (142/242; 59%). Sixty-six percent (158/241) believed that ancillary tests are sensitive and 55% (132/241) that they are specific for DNC. Respondents considered the following ancillary tests useful for DNC: four-vessel conventional angiography (211/241; 88%), nuclear imaging (179/240; 75%), computed tomography (CT) angiography (156/240; 65%), and CT perfusion (134/240; 56%).
Conclusion
There is variability in perceptions and approaches to DNC diagnosis among Canadian intensivists, and some practices are inconsistent with national recommendations.